All-in-one ETFs: a whole portfolio in one purchase
Every thread of this series — containers, diversification, the fee math, engine-and-brakes — converges on one product category that Canada does particularly well: the all-in-one ETF (formally, asset-allocation ETF). It is the closest thing to a complete answer the beginner investing world has produced.
The whole idea in one paragraph
An all-in-one ETF holds an entire diversified portfolio inside a single ticker: thousands of stocks across Canada, the U.S., Europe, Asia and emerging markets, plus (in most versions) a bond layer — and it rebalances itself automatically, forever, for an MER around 0.2%. One purchase, repeated monthly, is a legitimate complete investment strategy. Not a beginner’s compromise — the same product holds up at any portfolio size.
One family, different equity doses
Each provider offers the same portfolio at several risk levels — the number to watch is the equity percentage (the engine-to-brakes ratio from last article):
- 100% equity — e.g., XEQT (iShares), VEQT (Vanguard): maximum long-term growth, fully exposed to market swings.
- ~80% equity / 20% bonds — e.g., XGRO, VGRO: growth with a modest cushion.
- ~60/40 — e.g., XBAL, VBAL: the classic balanced portfolio.
- ~40/60 and below — e.g., VCNS: conservative territory.
Same global diversification throughout; only the dose differs. Which dose suits which situation is a function of horizon and temperament — the portfolios series next takes that question seriously rather than answering it in a sentence.
What the ~0.2% fee actually buys
Under the hood, one XEQT-type ticker wraps several underlying index funds and does the maintenance a diligent DIY investor would do:
- Global allocation kept at target (roughly: US ~45%, Canada ~25%, international developed ~20%, emerging ~10% for the equity portion).
- Automatic rebalancing — when one region surges, the fund quietly trims it back to target. No spreadsheets, no decisions, no temptation to tinker.
- Immense diversification — routinely 8,000–9,000 holdings. No single company, sector, or country can sink it.
A DIY multi-ETF portfolio can shave the fee to ~0.15% — real, but for most people not worth the annual rebalancing homework and the behavioural risk of fiddling. The all-in-one’s true product is discipline made automatic.
What holding one actually feels like
Honesty section. A 100%-equity all-in-one ETF will, at some point in any long holding period, be down 20–40% on paper. 2020 did it in five weeks. The product’s diversification did not prevent it — diversification prevents single-story disasters, not market-wide ones. What history shows is recovery plus long-term growth for those who kept buying through the dip; what no one can show is a schedule.
This is why the equity-percentage choice matters more than any other setting: the right all-in-one is the one whose worst month you can sleep through without selling.
The practical loop, end to end
The entire beginner playbook this site has been building, assembled:
- Open the right container (TFSA for most starters — see the accounts series).
- Set up an automatic transfer — $50, $200, $500 a month, whatever is sustainable.
- Buy the same all-in-one ETF each time, commission-free at several Canadian brokerages, fractional shares where supported.
- Ignore the price between purchases. Repeat for years.
Two minutes a month, fully diversified, self-maintaining, costing about $2 per $1,000 per year. Tickers named here are the widely-held examples every Canadian comparison discusses, not recommendations — the honest framing is that any of the major families (iShares, Vanguard, BMO’s equivalents) executes the same idea competently.
FAQ
Which one should I buy?
That’s a horizon-and-temperament question this site deliberately doesn’t answer for you. The observable pattern: younger investors with decades ahead gravitate to 80–100% equity versions; people who lose sleep at -30% choose more bonds. The portfolios series next walks through matching the dose to the situation.
Is putting everything into one ETF risky?
The wrapper is one ticker; the contents are ~9,000 securities across every developed market. The concentrated-looking choice is among the most diversified purchases available in Canada.
Do all-in-ones work in a TFSA? RRSP? FHSA?
Yes, all of them — they’re ordinary ETFs and fit any container. (Long-horizon FHSA money, sure; FHSA money needed for a purchase within a couple of years is usually parked safer — see the GIC article.)
Next in the journey: Model portfolios by risk level: five recipes, one dial